Sunday, November 23, 2008

'Milk' exposes paradox for screen's leading men

"Gay people must be 'out' to be counted."

Mark Caro writes:
Gus Van Sant's "Milk" isn't just a mainstream-minded Oscar candidate; it's also a rallying cry. With Sean Penn starring as Harvey Milk, the openly gay San Francisco supervisor who was gunned down in 1978, the movie (which opens Wednesday) makes its message clear: Gay people must be "out" to be counted. It's a timely theme given California's passage of anti-gay-marriage Proposition 8 this month, but there's also a certain irony: Here's a broadly targeted movie with marquee actors (James Franco, Josh Brolin and Emile Hirsch co-star), yet not only is none of the featured players openly gay, there isn't one openly gay leading man in all of Hollywood.

Even as gay people have become far more prominent and comfortable in culture and everyday life in the 30 years since Milk's death, not a single current A-list movie actor is "out." Could it be that big movie stars simply don't swing that way? That lead actors defy all percentages and likelihood to remain a strictly heterosexual crowd? Or is the more logical explanation that while Hollywood preaches openness, it is fearful to practice it? "Hollywood does not like anything that's going to threaten its bottom line," said Michael Jensen, editor of, a Web site devoted to gay and bisexual men in entertainment. "The idea of a gay leading man in a movie that's going to have a budget around $100 million—getting a studio to be the first one to take that chance is a challenging thing to do." As for the actors, Jensen continued, "there are already so many reasons for a casting director to turn a person down, and being an openly gay actor trying to get a romantic lead role, you're just giving them another reason." READ MORE

H/T: We Love Soaps

You May Have Missed
  • Josh Brolin's onetime low profile gets raised ever higher with roles in 'W' and 'Milk'
  • Josh Brolin on Prop 8
  • Josh Brolin and Barbra Streisand clashed over 'W'
  • Actors Josh Brolin and Jeffrey Wright were tased, pepper sprayed ..."N" word used
  • First Look: Josh Brolin as George W. Bush
  • Oscar Red Carpet: Arrivals
  • Barbra Streisand furious at Josh Brolin?
  • Josh Brolin to play George W. Bush!
  • I'll Have a Josh Brolin, Medium Rare, With a Side Order of Javier Bardem...
  • The Oscar nominees will be...
  • Josh Brolin has hit paydirt at last with the Coen Brothers' New Western, No Country For Old Men